CASE STUDY / PRIVATE EQUITY

Win rate from 11% to 25%, then an exit at more than double the prior valuation

A nine-month, $400K engagement across the full customer journey.

A sponsor-backed B2B analytics software company was winning 11% of its deals. Qualification came down to each rep’s opinion. The sales process changed from one rep to the next, and sales cycles were being measured incorrectly, so leadership had no objective read on the business.

Nine months later the win rate was 25%. Sales cycles ran almost 30% shorter, and deal ACV had more than doubled. The sponsor then sold the company to a strategic acquirer for more than twice the valuation set 18 months earlier.

We’ve kept the company and its sponsor anonymous. Every figure below comes from the engagement.

11% to 25%

Win rate

+127%

Deal ACV

~30%

Shorter sales cycle

$200M+

Enterprise value added in 18 months

Term

9-month retained agreement

Investment

$400,000

Scope

Full customer journey

How the nine months ran

Step 1

Assessment

Data, process and team analysis. Ends with a readout to the CEO, CRO, board and sponsor.

Step 2

Immediate triage

Systems, process and executive visibility. Fix what’s most broken first.

Step 3

Behavior change

Skill development and process adherence, measured against results.

Step 1: what the assessment found

We started with the company’s own record, before anyone’s opinion of it. That meant two calendar years of data across the full customer journey and every enablement and process asset the company had: ICP, personas, the prospecting, sales and CS processes, the forecasting process, RevOps metrics, stage entry and exit criteria, and the data dictionary.

Then we looked at how the work was really being done. We interviewed staff and leadership about their skills and their daily and weekly work. We listened to recorded discovery, demo and negotiation calls, and read the emails, demo decks and proposals reps were sending.

The findings went to the CEO and CRO as an executive summary, then to the board and the PE owner.

Area

What we found

Qualification

Subjective and inconsistent. Discovery was limited and undefined across the team.

Sales process

Undefined, and it varied wildly by rep. Sales cycles were measured incorrectly.

Rep skills

Uneven, the result of rapid promotion with limited development and coaching.

Systems and visibility

An underdeveloped CRM. No objective metrics, and executives couldn’t see activity or accomplishment.

Team handoffs

Marketing, business development, sales and CS rarely worked together. No handoff process existed.

Demos and value

Demos were show and tell, with no tie to the buyer’s problem. Little if any value selling.

Competition

Weak competitive intelligence that reps rarely addressed in a deal.

Negotiation

Ad hoc. It never involved give and take.

Step 2: triage the systems, the process and what executives can see

You can’t coach a team against numbers nobody trusts. So the first fixes went into the CRM, the reporting and the management layer.

  • Rebuilt the CRM. We restructured it to track data properly, capture the information that matters, and hold the team to a defined discovery framework (SPICED).

  • Gave executives a live view. We built executive dashboards and ran a weekly RevOps call that explained what the data meant: the good and bad trends in execution, and why they were happening.

  • Coached sales leadership every week. Managers learned how to analyze team performance, how to coach, and where to spend their time.

  • Wrote the company’s own playbook. A bespoke process that spelled out how to do each job: SDR, AE and CSM.

  • Tied the playbook to stage entry and exit criteria. Forecast accuracy improved by nearly 30% that quarter.

  • Reported monthly. A standing executive meeting covered findings and progress on the triage.

What the coaching surfaced

Most managers were doing their reps’ work for them.

That one habit explained two problems at once. New reps stayed weak because nobody was teaching them to do the job. And managers were too busy doing that job to manage.

Step 3: change behavior, then prove it with the numbers

A new process only pays off if people use it. This step was about adoption.

  • The team went through formal sales training, followed by two months of coaching on how to apply it.

  • Managers took monthly training on how to coach well.

  • We reviewed dozens of calls and demos, scored them, and gave feedback on adoption.

  • We matched each person’s execution to a metric-based performance review.

That last one turned the team. The data showed that the people who adopted the process were the ones outperforming. Every top performer was a top adopter, and they started leading by example. Buy-in stopped being a management request.

The results

Win rate

+127%

Before

11%

After

25%

Deal ACV (indexed, before = 100)

+127%

Before

100

After

227

Sales cycle (indexed, before = 100)

Almost 30% shorter

Before

100

After

~70

Win rate is shown in actual percentages. ACV and sales cycle are indexed to the starting point, so the bars show the size of the change and not dollar or day values.

Metric

Result

When

Forecast accuracy

Nearly 30% better

The quarter the playbook was tied to stage criteria

Win rate

11% to 25%

By the end of step 3

Sales cycle

Almost 30% shorter

By the end of step 3

Deal ACV

+127%

Over the engagement

The exit

The PE sponsor sold the company to a strategic acquirer. The price was more than double the valuation done just 18 months earlier, an increase of over $200M in enterprise value in that period.

We won’t claim all of that number. A lot goes into an exit price. But the fee was $400,000, which is 0.2% of the value added. And the revenue engine a buyer looked at had a higher win rate, bigger deals, shorter cycles and a more accurate forecast than the one we walked into.

What this means for a portfolio company you hold

  • Start with the company’s own data. Two years of customer journey data, plus calls and work product, showed what was broken. A benchmark wouldn’t have.

  • Fix visibility before skills. The CRM, the dashboards and the stage criteria came first. Forecast accuracy moved within a quarter.

  • Look hard at the manager layer. If managers are doing their reps’ work, headcount won’t fix the problem. Coaching will.

  • Let performance data make the case for adoption. Once the team saw that top adopters were top performers, the process spread on its own.

Frequently asked questions

Holding a portfolio company with a win rate nobody can explain?